How to Respond to Reviewers

Photo by Markus Winkler on Unsplash

bviously, you don’t need to agree with each recommendation that a reviewer makes, yet reacting amiably will help you when you need to decline a proposal or two. How you react to reviewers and editors can likewise go far toward a positive decision about your manuscript. At the point when you take part in a common and target talk with reviewers, you signal your duty to grant and willingness to permit the peer review system to improve your manuscript.

Some examples

· What you need to state: No one knows the answer to that question.

· What you should state: This is a substantial question, and we are effectively seeking after the appropriate response in our lab. Or on the other hand This is a valid and significant question, and we are interested what the outcomes would be. In any case, we are unaware of any researches that give the appropriate response.

· What you need to state: That experiment would take until the end of time!

· What you should state: The recommended experiment is interesting and would give extra data about…, however we feel that it falls outside the scope of this research.

· What you need to state: We’re not saying we demonstrated anything — that is only our hypothesis!

· What you should state: We agree that this clarification is theoretical right now, and we have edited the content to express that our summary is just proposed by our results. Note: you should roll out certain improvements to the text to additionally underscore that you were expressing a hypothesis, regardless of whether you felt it was clear previously.

Photo by Toa Heftiba on Unsplash

· What you need to state: You didn’t peruse what we wrote!

· What you should state: We didn’t mean to show [insert mistaken assertion by reviewer here], and we have consequently changed the text to specify that [insert right conclusion here]. Note: As in the past, you’ll need to change some phrasing.

· What you need to state: You are being so picky about language and formatting!

· What you should state: We apologize for this mistake, and we have amended the text as proposed.

· What you need to state: My English writing abilities are in a way that is much better than yours; why you are complaining about my mistakes?

· What you should state: Our original copy has been reviewed by a partner and modified to improve readability.



Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store

Providing productive support to authors and researchers at all steps of academic communication and publishing.